Around 9:15 p.m. on March 21, 1865. The Potomac River.
"Crazy, crazy. This is crazy!"
Mary Surratt, a woman who ran an inn in Washington, D.C., and held pro-Southern political views, was heading down Chesapeake Bay with Lincoln stuffed in a sack aboard her boat.
"Everyone's gone mad! There's no way we can get away with doing something like this! No way!"
The reason an ordinary woman with pro-Southern political leanings who lived in the North had suddenly become involved in the serious crime of kidnapping Lincoln was—
"Mother! Go back! We'll take care of it!"
her son.
"John! Stop this! Just go to Richmond and surrender! You'll spend about six months in a prisoner-of-war camp, then come home. If you do this, they'll execute you for sure! They'll hang you!"
For the sake of her son John Surratt, a Confederate spy, Mary had taken Lincoln from the other conspirators.
"No. This is our job. We planned this! Hand over President Lincoln, now. You don't even know where we're supposed to meet."
"John..."
"It's all right. This is for the greater good. I'll be back, Mother."
John Surratt had taken Lincoln to Richmond to avenge the Union soldiers who had seized his father's farm in Maryland and bankrupted his family, and killed his older brother in Texas.
*
9:35 p.m. on March 21, 1865. Campbell Hospital.
-I can do it! I can!
"Mrs. Lincoln. The play is almost over. I'll go fetch the President shortly. Please hold on to the speech for a moment."
"Of course. Thank you as always, Nikolai."
"It is always my honor."
Fifteen minutes before the play was due to end, according to the script, Lincoln's secretary Nikolai went to the presidential carriage to fetch him.
"?"
There was the minor mishap of the guard who was supposed to be stationed by the carriage being nowhere in sight, but Nikolai assumed it was just the usual laxity and opened the carriage door.
"Huh?"
But there was no one inside.
"Parker! Parker!!!"
The words 'The President is missing' flashed through Nikolai's mind. Panicking, he called for John Parker, Lincoln's day guard assigned by the Metropolitan Police Department.
"Yes! Good grief! What's the matter?"
Just as Nikolai had feared, Parker was drinking at a nearby tavern.
"Why are you over there? Where on earth has His Excellency gone?"
"Uh... well..."
Nikolai pressed Parker for an answer, but the man had been downing beer until just moments ago. There was no way he could know where the President had gone.
So he should have honestly said he hadn't seen him and didn't know where he had gone.
Yes. That's what he should have said.
"Oh! Uh, about an hour ago, he said the carriage was uncomfortable and he wanted to go somewhere with a bed! I've been here ever since!"
But, desperate to escape the problem facing him, he lied.
"Then why didn't you go with him?"
"Well, a guard can intimidate the public..."
"Hmm, that does sound like something the President would say. Still, I wish he'd considered the situation around him a little more."
Since Lincoln's thoughtfulness was famous throughout America, Nikolai fell for Parker's lie.
"You don't know exactly where he went?"
"He didn't say. Maybe he went to the hospital officers' ward or a prayer house?"
"Haa... We're running short on time. All right, then. We have to return after the speech, so sober up and get ready to leave."
"Yes, sir!"
Thanks to all this confusion, Lincoln was successfully kidnapped and taken all the way to Richmond.
*
3:13 a.m. on March 22, 1865. A telegram arrived at General Grant's tent near Petersburg, the supply route to Richmond, which he had surrounded.
-The eagle is missing.
"What?"
After the long war, Ulysses S. Grant had suffered a nervous breakdown—in modern terms, severe PTSD. Since he still hadn't gone to sleep, he was able to receive the telegram that arrived at three in the morning.
-Is it true the eagle is missing?
-It is true. The eagle is missing.
"That can't be."
But he also suffered from panic disorder, and he couldn't accept the sudden turn of events. His symptoms flared up.
"Hah... h-h..."
As his vision began to blur around the edges, General Grant fainted.
Even as he fell, however, he sent a telegram to the corps besieging Richmond.
-Presi-dent miss-ing. Rich-mond-
*
3:20 a.m. on March 22, 1865. Metropolitan Police Department, Washington, D.C.
"I've sent a telegram to Petersburg."
At around ten the previous evening, William Richard, chief superintendent of the Metropolitan Police Department, had received a report from Lincoln's secretary and the First Lady that the President was missing. Overcome with unease, he had immediately sent a telegram to the front.
If Lincoln had briefly disappeared because of a nervous breakdown or sleepwalking brought on by the long war, Richard could be dismissed at the very least—or, if things went badly, charged with treason and hanged. Even so, he had sent a telegram to the front.
"At least this should prevent a catastrophe."
He considered his own life a small price to pay compared to letting his carelessness overturn the entire war.
"I can trust General Grant. He'll deploy reserves to secure the approaches or tighten the checkpoints. Our police will seal off the city from now on. And... request martial law in Washington, D.C. from the War Department."
"What? Martial law?"
The police department's telegraph operator questioned Richard's excessive measures,
"Would you rather sit back and take it easy in a situation like this?"
but Richard had no reason to hesitate anymore.
"You can't put out a furnace once it's blazing. We'll work through the night until we find the President. And throw that bastard Parker in the brig right now!"
*
3:25 a.m. on March 22, 1865. Military Telegraph Office, U.S. War Department.
James Fry, Provost Marshal General of the War Department and the man who would become supreme commander of the martial-law forces if martial law were declared, was dragged to the military telegraph office in his pajamas.
"Provost Marshal General, I'm sorry to summon you so late at night."
"That's all right. Judging by the fact that the canaries dragged me here in my pajamas in the middle of the night, this must be a serious matter... Has something gone terribly wrong somewhere?"
He had every reason to be irritated at being summoned in the dead of night, but after four years of dealing with all manner of things, he graciously forgave the telegraph operators for their rudeness.
"Yes. Chief Superintendent Richard has requested martial law."
"Good grief, a rebellion? Or a serial killer? Let me think for a moment... Before that, wake the Secretary of War, too."
While considering the police department's request for martial law, he ordered them to wake Secretary of War Edwin Stanton so that martial law could be declared as soon as he reached a decision.
"James. Is there any reason to wake me at a time like this?"
"Mr. Secretary. His Excellency the President is missing."
"Declare martial law at once."
And twenty minutes later, at 3:45, martial law was declared in Washington, D.C.
*
Around 4:00 a.m. on March 22, 1865. The Union forces besieging Richmond.
"General, I've roused every soldier in the division. They fought on the defensive yesterday as well, so morale is in terrible shape."
Major General Edward Ord, commander of the division besieging Richmond, had been woken by a sentry who received General Grant's urgent telegram around three in the morning. He had immediately roused the entire force.
"That doesn't matter right now. The whole army, change of objective. From this moment on, don't let a single rat through any entrance around Richmond."
To prevent the catastrophe of Lincoln falling into Confederate hands, he decided to pound Richmond until the missing President was found.
"What? General, as I just reported, our troops fought on the defensive yesterday, and they're exhausted. They haven't even had proper rest after being roused early. We should at least wait until after breakfast to attack..."
"I know."
Of course, if they forced through an excessive blockade, the Confederates might launch a breakthrough while the Union troops were exhausted afterward.
If the Union forces besieging Petersburg were breached, they could be surrounded in turn, prolonging the war.
And if some unforeseeable disaster allowed the Confederates to retake Chesapeake Bay, Napoleon III of France might intervene in the Civil War through the puppet Mexican Empire.
"We still have to do it."
But all of that was better than Lincoln falling into Confederate hands.
"Bring the siege guns into position. Bombard the area around Richmond's walls, the nearby rivers, and every stretch of open ground where there might be a tunnel."
It was a risk with fewer unknowns than letting the Confederates capture Lincoln.
"If the kidnappers care about saving their own necks, they'll take the President hostage. Feed the sharpshooters breakfast, then let them sleep for four more hours. If there's a hostage situation, they'll have to pick off the kidnappers."
*
10:03 a.m. on March 22, 1865. Union Army Headquarters, City Point, Virginia.
-Chirp chirp
General Grant, who had fainted from his panic disorder, had slept so soundly that he woke feeling refreshed for the first time in ages.
-Trill
-A courier, sir!
Birds were singing, the morning sun shone bright, and the war outside was still unfolding at a frantic pace.
"Hah! This is no time for that! Adjutant! Adjutant!"
"Yes? Oh! General, what are you doing here?"
"Who are you? No, more importantly, what's the situation?"
"I'm Lieutenant Ackley, of an artillery regiment in the Army of the James! General Ord ordered us to bombard Richmond so the kidnappers can't get in!"
The unexpected siege of Richmond caused some minor confusion, but fortunately, everyone handled things competently, and no major disaster occurred.
"That's a relief. What a relief."
However,
unfortunately,
"I am Robert Edward Lee, commander-in-chief of the Confederate Army! We have Abraham Lincoln in our custody! Enter negotiations at once!"
And so, the story that began with a glass of beer did not end there.