In September 1865, things in South America were taking a very strange turn.
The Paraguayan War, which began in November 1864 when Paraguay invaded Brazil and crossed the Argentine border without authorization, was going extremely well for Paraguay.
"Mr. President. The chief of staff speaking. We’ve received a telegram from Humaitá Fortress. It says the defensive line has been strengthened by the construction of trenches."
"A defensive line in the rear? There’s no reason to build one."
They were so comfortable that they had even built a line of fortifications along their rear supply route.
"The messenger says it was effective enough to hold off a battalion of mixed Argentine and Uruguayan troops."
"A battalion couldn’t possibly have appeared behind us. Reports from the battlefield are always distorted. I’ll assume it was an Argentine reconnaissance platoon. Record the name of the commander who made the report, then severely punish him after the war."
In truth, Paraguay should have lost this war long ago.
Paraguay was fighting Brazil and Argentina, once core colonies of Portugal and Spain, as well as Uruguay, a Brazilian puppet state roughly equal in strength to Paraguay.
"By the way, how many troops are stationed at Humaitá Fortress? I’m sure I ordered them to begin assembling for the Argentine offensive in November."
"On paper, there are ten thousand, but a considerable number are noncombatants, such as engineers and arsenal workers. The actual field force is only six thousand. The enemy, on the other hand, claims to have a hundred thousand."
Besides, Paraguay was hardly a country that outclassed the Triple Alliance.
Paraguay had neither been a high-level administrative region during the colonial era, like Argentina, nor a legitimate imperial state, like Brazil.
"Fortunately, we seized most of the key positions with a surprise attack at the start of the war, so defending them is easy."
Even the justification for the war was flimsy.
"If only they’d cleared the way from the start... Tsk. That Mitre fellow really is a stubborn fool."
Paraguay could somehow justify declaring war on Brazil as part of the regional balance of power, but its illegal incursion into Argentina was unmistakable aggression.
"Um, Mr. President. About the commander you told me to record and punish just now..."
"What about him?"
That didn’t mean the military was an elite institution, either.
"It was Brigadier General Vicente Barrios."
There were plenty of officers who had studied in Europe, but many commanders had been promoted through their connections to President López, so rank and ability often didn’t match.
"Honestly, my brother-in-law... Delete the disciplinary record and change the report to say he won a victory with two regiments."
In other words, the army wasn’t particularly good, either.
"Our defenses are solid, while theirs are weak but numerous. If their so-called hundred thousand actually means thirty to fifty thousand, then we’re outnumbered five to one."
That might prompt a question.
How could a country with so many problems gain the upper hand against a Triple Alliance that greatly outclassed it?
The answer from Paraguay’s president and hereditary dictator, Francisco Solano López, was:
"Chief of staff, conscript more men."
Numbers.
"I understand the current conscription rate is eighteen percent. Raise it to twenty-five."
Military dictator López was prepared to send Paraguay’s entire population of six hundred thousand to its death. By conscripting soldiers on a massive scale, he was able to overwhelm the three nations that relied on voluntary enlistment.
"Your Excellency, we can conscript them, but there’s a problem."
But that had only been true at the start of the war.
"We’re short on weapons, aren’t we?"
"No. The previous president stockpiled plenty of British Enfield rifles, so we have enough weapons. But we’re running short of nonessential goods, like food for civilian distribution."
Paraguay had been a landlocked country from the start, an inherent limitation that made it unsuited to a long war.
"Weapons are only available from places like France, but nonessential goods such as food, scrap metal, and clothing can be found just about anywhere. If only we could open up the La Plata River."
Just as Brazil’s blockade of the La Plata River—the only waterway connecting Paraguay to the Atlantic—had immediately cut the country off, Paraguay was gradually losing the momentum it had enjoyed at the start of the war.
"Some in the military are suggesting we win one major battle at this point and then negotiate. Lieutenant General Benigno López, the military supply commander, and Finance Minister Bedoya asked me to be sure to pass their suggestion along to you."
"Hmm. So my younger brother and my brother-in-law think so too. I was thinking the same thing. Besides, if we break through the La Plata blockade, Prussia may change its mind. Merchants don’t like coming where there’s no way in."
Then, two weeks earlier, Prussia had notified Paraguay that it was suspending arms sales. Faced with that as well, the president and his inexperienced military leadership decided to gamble.
"Gather the navy. We’ll launch a surprise attack on the Brazilian fleet and break through the blockade on the La Plata."
Without realizing that they were dragging South America into an even deeper quagmire.
*
The Paraná River, one of the upper tributaries of the La Plata River.
The Brazilian fleet blockading the La Plata had anchored near an island in the Paraná River, keeping Paraguay cut off.
And the morale of the Brazilian sailors guarding this vital strategic point—the only route linking Paraguay to the outside world and the sole supply line for the Triple Alliance armies of Brazil, Argentina, and Uruguay—was...
"Ah! I wish I could be exploited for fourteen hours a day in some bourgeois factory!"
"Don’t say that so loudly. People will hear you."
"Let them hear."
Completely shattered.
"Ahh, I want to go home!"
"You have a home to go back to?"
"Of course not."
"Same here!"
There was, surprisingly, only one reason.
"Keep it down. Did they drag you into the army?"
"How’d you know? They conscripted me on my way home from work."
"Me too..."
They had all been forcibly conscripted.
"We’ve both been dragged here, so let’s not fight each other."
That was only natural.
Although the three countries had somehow formed an alliance, the fundamental reason for the war was Paraguay’s surprise attack.
The volunteers who had enlisted out of a sense of duty had died long ago, leaving the front lines packed with men who had been forced into service.
"That’s why you can’t trust white people. Things were better in the old days!"
And every one of those conscripts was vulnerable—Black paupers or mixed-race beggars, with no one to speak up for them if they were dragged away.
"That’s going too far. You’d have been a slave back then."
"Well, I suppose being poor is better than being a slave. Ah! I want to be exploited for labor and have my dignity crushed in Rio, like Michael Number Three!"
"You lunatic. I’m going crazy myself, so give it a rest."
"Ah!!! Me too!! Just like Michael Number Three!!"
In short, they were mestizos and Black people.
"Michael Number Three? What’s that?"
"You haven’t read that novel? What a waste of a life."
"I mean, I’ve read Michael Number One and Michael Number Two, but I haven’t read Number Three yet."
"This isn’t Romeo and Juliet. What are Michael Number One and Michael Number Two?"
So everyone knew about novels with socialist themes, too.
"I’m just about done with it. Here, have a look."
"Oh. So Michael Number Three is the title. Let’s see... But I’m illiterate."
"I figured. I’ll read it to you."
Out of sight of the white officers, they hid away somewhere, pretending to scrub the deck or check supplies, and shared socialist ideas.
""Ah! I want to suffer an industrial accident in a factory in Rio!!""
Naturally, an army like that had no chance of fighting properly.
-Prepare for battle! Enemy sighted ahead! Don’t be afraid! Our ship is an ironclad!
The same was true on the Riachuelo River on September 11, 1865.
-Prepare to ram! Brace for impact!
"Aaaah!"
"We’ve run aground! The ship’s listing!"
At the start of the war, Brazil had succeeded in destroying Paraguay’s entire navy with ramming attacks. But they had built up too much speed, and their steamships ran aground on sandbars or capsized and were wrecked.
-It’s hand-to-hand combat! Everyone, draw your swords!
"That’s right! Stabbing the bigwigs in the back will solve everything! Listen up, boys! It’s a mutiny! We might as well go to Paraguay!"
-Aagh! You cowards! If you were going to mutiny aboard ship, you should’ve done it sooner... You’ll all be eaten by those Paraguayan cannibals!
"Bullshit! Not one word from you stuffed shirts has been true!"
While trying to salvage the capsized ironclads, Brazil’s sail-and-steam ships lost the boarding battle to the Paraguayan navy and were captured.
"Hey, is this really okay? I wasn’t planning on mutinying..."
"You don’t have a home to go back to anyway! Let’s go to Paraguay and make something of ourselves!"
"Yeah. The mutiny’s already started. I’m not asking for much. Just make me a captain!"
At six in the morning on September 11, 1865, the Battle of Riachuelo ended in a Paraguayan victory.
"Ha ha... I’ve heard things like this happen all the time on the battlefield... Anyway, welcome, everyone. I’m Brigadier General Vicente Barrios of Paraguay. I promise I’ll find each of you a position."
*
After the Battle of Riachuelo, the war in South America grew increasingly ugly.
First, after gaining control of the La Plata River with a few sailing ships, Paraguay began importing nonmilitary goods through the Atlantic.
In response, the Triple Alliance introduced conscription and unleashed a manpower offensive against Paraguay.
But with the La Plata River lost, the Triple Alliance had to transport supplies by land through South America’s swamps and jungles, and suffered more casualties from disease and injuries than from combat.
Even so, the Triple Alliance’s greater size allowed it to keep up the offensive against Paraguay.
Brazilian, Argentine, and Uruguayan forces made it to Paraguay in a desperate push through jungles, swamps, and crocodile-infested waters, then charged into the Paraguayan trenches. The Paraguayans stopped the Triple Alliance’s attacks by throwing men into the trenches.
Paraguay had already lost too many lives to give up the war, either.
In the end, President López held out by raising the conscription rate from twenty-five percent to forty, then from forty to sixty, and finally demanding service from every man and even conscripting women.
The people of Paraguay willingly crawled into the trenches to ensure their nation’s survival.
Juan, a father of one son and two daughters from Asunción, was one of them.
Juan enlisted in August 1865 and came home dead in October. His son Matías tore off his father’s mustache and stuck it above his own lip.
Carmen tried to stop Matías, who had pasted on his father Juan’s mustache, from heading to the trenches. But Matías shook off her hand and promised he would come back alive.
Matías’s older sister María said he would die, but his younger sister Liz looked at him with admiration. Before long, she shaved her head, enlisted as a female soldier, and entered the trenches on the western bank of the La Plata River.
The four shillings paid for Liz’s hair, which had been sold to England, arrived later than the notices informing the family that Matías and Liz had fallen in battle.
Even as this went on, four Paraguayan sail-and-steam ships patrolled the La Plata River, and countless European merchant vessels passed through.
The Krupp bronze cannons embezzled by some Mexican colonel and the Gatling guns captured by the Confederate States of America both turned into ample quantities of gold and silver as soon as they sailed up the La Plata.
The merchant ships carried that gold to Africa, where they bought coffee, ivory, and ebony, then headed for Russia and North America.
The merchants sold ebony, coffee, and ivory in New York and Odessa, bought cheap grain, and returned to their home countries.
Back in Europe, the merchants heard a word of praise at the grain exchange from a government official whose name included 'von,' then received an arms-trade permit stamped by Chief of the General Staff Helmuth von Moltke and signed by Prime Minister Bismarck. They loaded 1862-pattern muzzle-loading rifles and bronze cannons into their cargo holds and sailed for North America, bound for the La Plata River.