As his introduction made clear, Wilhelm's tutor, Hinzpeter, was a man who followed Princess Victoria's wishes.
"Your Highness. You've raised your right hand again."
"But my left arm won't go up..."
"What kind of excuse is that? And didn't we agree you'd get a swat every time you made an excuse?"
"I did agree, but... still..."
"We certainly did. Then, as you promised, I'll strike you once each time you use your right hand. Roll up your trouser legs, Your Highness."
-Smack! Smack!
"Ow! Weren't you only going to hit me once?!"
"I used my discretion as your tutor and gave you one extra. Do you have a complaint?"
"Yes!"
"Even if you do, bear it. That's where refinement begins."
To be precise, he was someone who catered to Princess Victoria's tastes.
"I'll give you a test. You have five minutes, so try to answer as many as you can."
Hinzpeter seemed like the embodiment of Princess Victoria's hatred of people with disabilities, speaking of contempt for the disabled as though it were the natural order of the world.
No, perhaps the modern era is simply too accepting.
The very idea of embracing people with disabilities is relatively new.
Until earlier eras, people treated the disabled as 'another species, not one of us.'
Of course, ordinary people might pity and help them, or else ignore them, but others like Hitler—
No, this isn't the time to talk about that. Let's get back to it.
"Hmm. Young master, you're good at the humanities. You know a lot of vocabulary, too. You're slow at arithmetic, but your calculations are accurate, while you're weak at calculus and geometry. Let's focus on mathematics."
Hinzpeter seemed like the personification of Princess Victoria, and was quite liberal.
He applied a lenient standard to me, an able-bodied person, offering some praise and helping plan my future.
"Your Highness. Sigh... why couldn't you solve it?"
"Huh? Because I don't know how..."
"Is not knowing an excuse?"
But he was different with Wilhelm.
"If your body is impaired, then your mind must be sharp. You know that Your Highness, born with an innate disadvantage compared to others, has to be twice as outstanding just to measure up."
No matter how well Wilhelm did, Hinzpeter never praised him and simply took it for granted.
"But if I don't know, I don't know... I don't even know what the capital sigma symbol means in math."
"So not knowing is an excuse? You should at least try to solve it even if you don't know. This all comes down to a lack of will."
He criticized what Wilhelm couldn't do, and berated him for being lazy whenever he didn't know something.
"But why are you only like this with me? I got more questions right."
"Your Highness. Is the position of the royal family's heir the same as being the Prime Minister's adopted son? The young master might become some minister, a colonel or division commander in some army, or even a general if he does well. But God has called the royal family's heir to the vocation of king. Naturally, the effort required is different."
Even when called out for holding them to different standards, he justified his behavior with a Calvinist attitude.
Above all, the cruelest thing Hinzpeter did was—
"Prince Wilhelm, I actually envy you."
"Why?"
"Because God has given you an obvious trial, hasn't He? If it were me, I would have used the disability in my left arm to discipline myself without end. Even if I could never overcome the disability and become normal, wouldn't simply moving my left arm in everyday life prove God's glory? Try thinking of your left arm not as a disability, but as God's choice."
He framed Wilhelm's disability as a matter of Wilhelm's will.
"Ugh... *sniff*..."
"Who told you to cry? Roll up your trouser legs. If you can't use your left arm, you have to strive to overcome it. This is laziness. Do you want to become a lazy king?"
"Waaah..."
-Smack! Smack! Smack! Smack!
"I'll keep hitting you until you stop crying. Your Highness, I'm doing all this for your sake. Would I do this if you were just an ordinary worker's child? If you had been born with a calling to work as a mere factory laborer, I wouldn't be doing this either. I would simply point out your laziness in leaving your left arm unused and move on. But that's not who you are, is it? This is all to save Your Highness's soul."
So I—
"Tutor, I have a question."
I decided I had to crush Hinzpeter.
"Yes. What are you curious about?"
I had to crush every last bit of him, until not even dust remained.
"Tutor, why is overcoming His Highness's disability in his left shoulder proof of God's glory?"
"Ah, I see I didn't explain properly. Why is His Highness's disability in his left shoulder a means of proving God's glory? Because it's a visible weakness. To use an analogy, His Highness's left shoulder is a stage on which God's glory is demonstrated."
"All of that is nothing but bad faith—Mauvaise foi. Aren't vocation and destiny both just self-deception dressed up as something God ordained?"
"Ha ha... You're still young, young master. Then are you saying you were born with a disability and no calling? Without any meaning? If so, that's an enormous waste. Isn't it more bad faith to dismiss it as self-deception? That's an excuse made by those who flee from proving God's glory."
Of course, Hinzpeter took my words for the commonplace questions of a young child and refuted them in a tedious, highbrow manner.
In response, I—
"So God made it happen?"
—gave him an equally tedious and highbrow answer.
"There are no coincidences in this world. What can we do when that's how reality is? As I said before, if all of this were coincidence, it would mean the world was being wasted. So every circumstance in this world is one God has ordained. Everything in the world is part of God's plan."
Like the religious fanatic he was, Hinzpeter countered my rebuttal with religion again.
This might raise a question.
Namely, 'Since there's no right or wrong in ideology, shouldn't this conversation just go in circles?'
As that suggests, ideologies have no right or wrong.
If you want to live a stable life, Hinzpeter's Calvinism is actually closer to the right answer.
But right now, there's no need to overthink it.
This debate didn't begin to argue that Calvinism was wrong,
"There is no such rule in the world. There is only universality, and a bias toward people making universal choices."
It began to show that Hinzpeter was wrong.
In fact, the moment he answered in earnest, Hinzpeter's defeat was already certain.
Because right now, I'm a four-year-old with a good vocabulary.
"Don't try to confine His Highness within universality, a sandcastle built by mankind! His Highness mustn't follow an average that includes even the depraved who have abandoned God! To act in such a depraved manner is to turn one's back on God's will!"
Just as I'd expected, Hinzpeter engaged in the debate in earnest, even letting his speech fall apart.
"So, you can't?"
And I kept pressing Hinzpeter without much concern.
"Anyone can act in bad faith. They can sleep in late in the morning or let their lessons go in one ear and out the other. But even if they choose such bad faith, they'll ultimately be people of good faith. They chose to act in bad faith in good faith."
Calvinism as an ideology was neither right nor wrong, but Hinzpeter as a person was wrong.
Because—
"What is truly impossible is what a disability makes impossible. Moving His Highness's left arm isn't a choice available to him. Before will even comes into it, there is no choice. If willpower alone could do everything, people would have been flying long ago. But they haven't, because humans don't have wings. In the first place, 'flying' isn't an option available to humans. His Highness Wilhelm is the same. He is someone for whom 'using his left shoulder' is no longer an option."
Because people merely follow ideologies; they aren't ideologies themselves.
Ideologies and science belong to different domains, so neither can defeat the other; but people can't defeat science.
"Prince Wilhelm can give up his right to the throne at any time. But he hasn't, has he? He's faced the role of prince head-on. Isn't that the very definition of Calvinist perseverance? To face the position of prince without running away is
E
ngagement, that is."
At the same time, people can't defeat ideologies, either.
"Th-that makes no sense! If there's no calling or destiny, then there's no reason to live!"
"I know."
People are always people.
And the world people live in is always much the same.
"That's absurd. Then what on earth are people born for?"
Hinzpeter's question, from the nineteenth century, was one people in the modern era asked all the time, too.
And people in the modern era actually knew the answer to that question quite well.
In modern times, it had been called things like the 'pelican mindset' and 'gigachad,' but the underlying idea was this:
"You have to find that out as you live."
'How should I know?'
"People keep living anyway, don't they?"
Even when they don't know, people keep living.
Because people aren't creations made by God, but living beings born of other people.
But humans became too intelligent to live as mere organisms.
"If there's no mission, if there's no mission! If there's no mission and you deny God, then why don't you kill yourself?! You won't even go to hell anyway!"
They became so intelligent that they sought a purpose beyond being fruitful and multiplying—and so introspective that the idea of being born without a special mission could drive them to suicide.
But—
"Why would I?"
Do people absolutely have to be born with a special mission?
Since the days of ancient Greece, famous scholars have said this:
If you don't know, find out.
"If you don't have a mission, make one."
I was the same.
"Tutor, there's something I'd like to ask you. You keep talking about God's mission, God's will, and all that..."
That's why Hinzpeter was wrong.
"Who exactly is the God you believe in?"
Hinzpeter wasn't a Calvinist, but someone who interpreted Calvinism liberally.
"Where on earth did you learn such wicked ideas?"
And so, I won the debate with Hinzpeter.
"Until last year, I studied basic general education under a private tutor, too. Though I only received six months of instruction, don't look down on private tutoring."
"Who on earth was this tutor?!"
Hinzpeter had lost the debate and flailed, but nothing could change the outcome.
There wasn't much to say about what happened afterward.
"Mr. Schopenhauer."
I just teased Hinzpeter as a victory celebration.
"Lies! Professor Schopenhauer died in Frankfurt in September 1860!"
Of course, it was a lie.
I only knew Schopenhauer was a nineteenth-century figure; I didn't know when or where he died.
"Really? Well, he did seem rather unwell."
But did that matter when I was humiliating him?
"Impossible. Mr. Schopenhauer died when you were a baby! I even wrote him a letter myself!"
Having won the debate, I got carried away and teased Hinzpeter.
It was a bit like bullying him, but Hinzpeter flopped around like a fish just pulled from the water, and teasing him was so much fun I couldn't stop.
But even that humiliation didn't last long.
"You must be confused, you halfwit. Picking a fight with a five-year-old."
"Aaaah!!!!"
In the end, Hinzpeter couldn't take it and ran away.
"B-but, Albert. Is that true?"
"Hmm? What do you mean?"
After Hinzpeter, who had lost a serious debate to a child who hadn't even turned five yet, ran off, Wilhelm, who had silently cheered me on, asked me a question.
"What you said about learning from Schopenhauer. I know Schopenhauer, too."
He was asking whether what I'd told Hinzpeter was true.
"Ah, that?"
Come to think of it, while crushing Hinzpeter, I'd gotten excited and crossed a line.
Still, it wasn't a big problem.
"Of course it was a lie."
Because no one in the world would take a four-year-old's words seriously.
"That Hinzpeter fellow isn't much of a tutor, is he? He went on about refinement, then ended up shouting and running out. It's all because he lacks habitus. Hmm, shall we play soldiers?"
"Yeah! This time let's play Mexico!"
A few minor things did happen after that,
-I'm telling you, that child is strange!!
-I never imagined you'd be such an incompetent tutor. Here's your travel money. Don't come back to work tomorrow.
Anyway, it was Hinzpeter's fault.